Granvemhoacvibimdeol
Hedge Accounting October 2026 9 мин

AASB 9 Hedge Accounting for Commodity Derivatives: What Treasury Teams Get Wrong Before the First Reporting Date

Treasury team reviewing AASB 9 hedge documentation

The standard sequence at many Australian industrial businesses runs like this: the derivative position is negotiated and confirmed, the deal is announced internally as a completed hedge programme, and the finance team is then asked to prepare the hedge accounting documentation. That sequence is backwards, and it is the single most reliable predictor of a hedge accounting failure at the first reporting date. AASB 9 requires that hedge documentation exist at the inception of the hedging relationship — not as a retrospective description of a trade already executed, but as a prospective statement of what is being hedged, with what instrument, against what risk, assessed by what method. When documentation is prepared after the fact, it tends to describe the trade as executed rather than the exposure as it actually exists, and those two descriptions are frequently not the same thing. We walk through the four most common documentation and designation errors we have observed in Australian industrial commodity hedge programmes, in the order in which they typically surface.

Defining the Hedged Item Too Broadly

The hedged item in an AASB 9 commodity hedge must be specifically identified. A designation that reads 'commodity price exposure arising from procurement activities' is not a hedged item — it is a category. AASB 9 requires the hedged item to be defined with sufficient precision that its fair value or cash flow changes can be measured reliably and compared to the changes in the hedging instrument. For a commodity hedge, this typically means specifying the volume of physical purchases, the pricing period, the reference index or contract price mechanism, and the delivery or assessment date. The practical consequence of a vague hedged item definition is that the effectiveness assessment cannot be performed consistently across reporting periods. The assessor is forced to make interpretive decisions about what falls within the hedged item at each assessment date, and different interpretations in successive periods produce effectiveness results that are not comparable. When an auditor reviews the programme, the inconsistency in hedged item definition is often the first finding — and it tends to unravel the hedge accounting designation for prior periods as well as the current one. The fix is to define the hedged item in the same level of detail that appears in the physical procurement contract: specific volume, specific pricing mechanism, specific dates. If that level of detail is not available at the time the derivative is executed, the hedge accounting designation should be deferred until it is, and the derivative should be carried at fair value through profit and loss in the interim.

Define the hedged item with the same precision as the physical procurement contract before executing any derivative.

Setting the Hedge Ratio by Convention

A hedge ratio of one-to-one — hedging the full notional volume of the physical exposure with an equivalent notional of the derivative instrument — is the default assumption in many treasury teams. It is also frequently incorrect. AASB 9 requires the hedge ratio to reflect the actual quantities of the hedged item and the hedging instrument that the entity uses in the economic hedge. If the physical procurement volume is one thousand tonnes per quarter and the derivative is sized at one thousand tonnes, the ratio is one-to-one only if the derivative price and the physical price move in exactly the same proportion. Where basis risk exists — and we have covered in detail why it almost always does — the optimal hedge ratio is typically less than one-to-one. The minimum variance hedge ratio, derived from the regression of physical price changes against derivative price changes over a historical sample, will in most cases produce a ratio below unity. Using a one-to-one ratio when the statistically derived ratio is, say, zero point eight five does not just introduce a small imprecision — it creates a systematic over-hedge that will show up as ineffectiveness in the AASB 9 assessment and may push the programme outside the permitted effectiveness range. The pre-trade calculation of the optimal hedge ratio is a standard exercise in risk management. It requires the same historical price data used for the basis risk analysis. If that data has been gathered — and it should have been, before any instrument was selected — the hedge ratio calculation adds perhaps one additional hour of analytical work. There is no operational justification for skipping it.

Calculate the minimum variance hedge ratio from historical price data before designating any hedging relationship.

Choosing the Wrong Effectiveness Assessment Method

AASB 9 permits several methods for assessing hedge effectiveness, and the choice of method has material consequences for the stability and robustness of the hedge accounting designation over time. The standard requires that the assessment demonstrate three things: an economic relationship between the hedged item and the hedging instrument, that credit risk does not dominate value changes, and that the hedge ratio reflects the quantities actually used. It does not specify a single numerical test or a minimum threshold percentage — the old eighty to one hundred and twenty five percent bright-line rule from the superseded AASB 139 does not apply under the current standard. Despite this, many treasury teams continue to apply the dollar-offset method as if the old threshold still governed. The dollar-offset method — comparing the change in fair value of the hedging instrument to the change in fair value of the hedged item as a ratio — is sensitive to small absolute changes in value and can produce highly volatile results in low-price-movement periods, even for economically sound hedging relationships. A regression-based method or a scenario analysis that demonstrates the economic relationship across a range of price outcomes is more robust and better aligned with what AASB 9 actually requires. The method should be selected before the hedge is designated, documented in the hedge designation document, and applied consistently at each subsequent assessment date. Changing the method between assessment periods raises questions about the integrity of the programme that are difficult to answer satisfactorily to an auditor.

Select and document the effectiveness assessment method before designation, and apply it consistently at every subsequent reporting date.

Failing to Separate the Intrinsic and Time Value of Options

When the hedging instrument is an option — a put, a call, or a collar structure — AASB 9 permits an entity to designate only the intrinsic value of the option as the hedging instrument, excluding the time value. This election has significant accounting consequences and is frequently misunderstood or overlooked. If the option is designated in its entirety, changes in both intrinsic value and time value flow through the cash flow hedge reserve, subject to the effectiveness assessment. If only the intrinsic value is designated, the time value is accounted for separately — it is either recognised in other comprehensive income and reclassified to profit or loss when the hedged item affects profit, or it is recognised directly in profit or loss as it unwinds, depending on whether the option is transaction-related or time-period-related. The practical implication for a commodity put option used to hedge a series of quarterly procurement transactions is that the time value separation election, if made, reduces income statement volatility from option time value decay while keeping the effectiveness assessment focused on the intrinsic value, which tracks the underlying price movement more cleanly. The election must be made at inception of the hedge designation and cannot be changed retrospectively. Treasury teams that execute option-based commodity hedges without considering this election — often because the decision is left to the finance team after the trade is confirmed — end up with a default accounting treatment that may not reflect the programme's economic intent. This is the category of AASB 9 technical detail where early engagement with the external auditor, before the trade is executed, consistently produces better outcomes than post-trade remediation.

Decide at inception whether to separate option time value from intrinsic value — this election cannot be reversed after designation.

We use cookies on this site

This website uses cookies to support core functionality and to collect anonymised analytics data about how visitors use the site. We do not use cookies for targeted advertising or cross-site tracking. You may accept all cookies, reject non-essential cookies, or manage your preferences at any time. For full details refer to our Cookie Policy.

Strictly necessary site cookies Required

These cookies enable core website navigation and page access functions. They cannot be disabled without impairing the basic operation of the site.

Analytics and performance cookies

These cookies collect anonymised data on pages visited and time spent, used only to improve the technical performance of the site.